Trust Nomination vs Non-Trust Nomination: What’s the Impact on Your Beneficiaries?

Table of Contents

When it comes to life insurance, one of the crucial decisions you need to make is how to nominate your beneficiaries. In Malaysia, you have two primary options: trust nomination and non-trust nomination. Understanding the differences between these can significantly impact your loved ones in the event of your passing. Let’s delve into what these terms mean, how they work, and how they affect your beneficiaries.

What is Trust Nomination?

Trust nomination is a way to assign your life insurance policy’s death benefits to specific beneficiaries, creating a legal statutory trust.

  • Automatic Trust: In Malaysia, when you nominate your spouse, children, or parents (when you are single), a statutory trust is automatically created under the FSA 2023 (Financial Services Act 2013).
  • Control: With a trust nomination, the Trustee’s consent would be required if you want to make any contractual changes that affect the nominees.  You effectively lose control over the policy’s benefits once the nomination is made. The benefits will be distributed according to the trust’s terms.
  • Protection: This is very important, upon death, the insurance proceeds do not form part of the estate.  The trust nomination ensures that the benefits are protected from creditors and go directly to the beneficiaries.

Example: Imagine you nominate your spouse and children as beneficiaries under a trust nomination for your RM500,000 life insurance policy.  Upon your death, the insurance company will pay the benefits directly to them, skip all the messy and troublesome probate processes, bypassing any claims from your creditors.

What is Non-Trust Nomination?

Non-trust nomination allows you to nominate any individual as a beneficiary without creating a trust.

  • Flexibility: You retain control over the policy and can change the nomination at any time.
  • Distribution: The benefits are not protected from creditors and can be claimed by the deceased’s estate.
  • Administration: In the event of death, the benefits form part of the estate and are distributed according to the will or the Distribution Act 1958 (amendment 1997) if there is no will.

Example: Suppose you nominate your brother as a beneficiary under a non-trust nomination for your RM500,000 life insurance policy. Upon your death, the benefit will be paid to your brother as an executor (instead of as a beneficiary) and then your brother needs to use that money to settle your outstanding liabilities, and then further distribute the balance of insurance proceed according to Will (if any), or according to Distribution Act (if no Will).

Key Differences and Considerations

  1. Control:
    • Trust Nomination: Your Trustee has control over the policy’s contractual benefits once the nomination is made.
    • Non-Trust Nomination: You retain control and can change the nomination anytime.
  2. Protection from Creditors:
    • Trust Nomination: Benefits are protected from creditors and go directly to the beneficiaries.
    • Non-Trust Nomination: Benefits can be claimed by creditors as part of the estate.
  3. Distribution Process:
    • Trust Nomination: Benefits are paid directly to the nominated beneficiaries.
    • Non-Trust Nomination: Nominees receive the proceeds as executors.  Needs to settle debts, then distribute the balance of funds according to the will or the laws of intestacy, potentially reducing the sum, and delaying the process.

Which One Should You Choose?

Choosing between trust nomination and non-trust nomination depends on your specific needs, family structure, and financial situation. Here are some scenarios to consider:

  • Opt for Trust Nomination if:
    • You want to ensure that your spouse, children, or parents receive the benefits directly without any interference from creditors.
    • You prefer a straightforward distribution process without involving the estate.
  • Choose Non-Trust Nomination if:
    • You want to retain control over your policy and the flexibility to change beneficiaries as needed.
    • You are nominating individuals outside your immediate family, such as friends or extended relatives.

Examples and Impact

  1. Trust Nomination Example:
    • Scenario: Johnny Lim has a life insurance policy worth RM1 million and nominates his wife and children under a trust nomination.
    • Impact: Upon Johnny’s death, the insurance company directly pays the RM1 million to his wife and children. This ensures financial security for his family without any claims from creditors.
  2. Non-Trust Nomination Example:
    • Scenario: David has a life insurance policy worth RM1 million and nominates his brother as a non-trust nomination.
    • Impact: Upon David’s death, the RM1 million is paid to his brother as an executor. If David has outstanding debts, creditors can claim against the estate from his brother. This might delay the distribution and reduce the actual benefit his brother receives.

Conclusion

Both trust nomination and non-trust nomination have their advantages and drawbacks.  It’s crucial to understand how each works and its implications for your beneficiaries. Consulting with a financial advisor or estate planner can help you make the best choice tailored to your specific circumstances.

Remember, the goal is to ensure that your loved ones are taken care of and that your wishes are honored. Take the time to consider your options and make an informed decision that provides peace of mind for you and your family.

Table of Contents

Scroll to Top